Education Institute of Hawaii
An Independent Catalyst for Improving Public Education in Hawaii

Education Institute’s Blog: A Site to Discuss Empowerment for Hawaii’s Public Schools


Hawaii Board of Education

Public Meeting Broadcast Recordings
provided as a service to our community

HIBOE General Business Meeting Agenda
Public Testimony
Superintendent's Report
Hawaii Business Roundtable Presentation on Strategic Priorities
State Public Charter School Commission's Annual Report
Board Approval of 2017 Legislative Report on the State's public charter schools - Board Annual Report
Board Approval on School Community Council request for exceptions to collective bargaining agreements, statutory waivers, and waivers of Board policy for School Year 2016-2017 for Baldwin High School, Aiea High School, and Maui High School
Board Approval on appointment of Board Designee, Rodney Luke to the School Community Council Exception Review Committee

HIBOE Student Achievement Committee Meeting Agenda
Public Testimony (none)
Complex Area Superintendent Report: Special Education in the Farrington - Kaiser - Kalani Complex Area

HIBOE General Business Meeting Agenda
Public Testimony
Superintendent's Report
Board Approval of amendment to BOE Finance & Infrastructure Committee Charter recommending, in addition to other changes, that members "will either possess or obtain basic abilities in financial matters".
Board Approval of amended School Food Services Follow-up Review with updates to the management plan and updates on the completion of progress of completion for the action plan to be reported to through the audit committee quarterly updates.
Board appointed member Kili Namau'u as the Board's liaison to the Hawaii State Public Library System.
Board Approval to amend the superintendent evaluation general timeline for the 2017-2018 school year,

HIBOE Student Achievement Committee Agenda
Public Testimony
Complex Area Superintendent Report: Special Education in the Pearl City - Waipahu Complex Area
Presentation on annual reporting of the 2017-2020 DOE & BOE Joint Strategic Plan Indicators for Goal 1 (Student Success)
Committee Action on designation of Hawaii State Public Library System Liaison

HIBOE Audit Committee Agenda
Agenda Discussion Item(s): Presentation of the Department of Education's Internal Audit Plan -- Quarterly Update through September 30, 2017
Action Item(s): Committee Action on School Food Services Follow-up Review -- Amended
Public Testimony: none

HIBOE General Business Meeting Agenda


Discussion Items - Community Stakeholder Presentations

In My Opinion: State DOE Structure is Dysfunctional

by Ray L’Heureux appearing in Pacific Business News, 3/27/15

Ray L'Heureux, EIH Vice Chair & President-Elect

Ray L'Heureux, EIH Vice Chair & President-Elect

A recent survey of public school principals suggests that the governance structure and culture of Hawaii’s Department of Education are dysfunctional.

School principals say they need more flexibility in determining who will or will not work in their schools, and the authority to seek support services outside the DOE to better serve the children. My own experiences convince me that their criticism of the existing system is spot on.

While serving as a Marine, I had many positions of responsibility, including in strategic and management operations in the U.S. Pacific Command, and in command of the presidential helicopter squadron where I was responsible for the safety and transportation of President George W. Bush and then President Barack Obama.

Following that 30-year career, I happily signed on as the assistant superintendent in charge of facilities and support services for the Hawaii State Department of Education. My children had graduated from public high schools in Hawaii, and I saw the DOE position as an opportunity to serve the people — and especially the children — of my adopted home.

Although not an educator by training, I knew that the DOE’s operational and educational components would have to be inextricably connected and mutually supported if the children were to be served effectively.

Hawaii’s DOE is the ninth-largest school district in the country and the only one that encompasses an entire state. With more than 30,000 employees, annual expenditures of $1.8 billion and 256 schools on seven islands, clear lines of authority — and the close alignment of authority with accountability — are critically important.

More than two years in the state office convinced me that meaningful progress will be impossible without major change in the DOE’s governance structure and culture.

We currently have the opposite of a schools-centered or schools-empowered system. Rather than empower school-level professionals to use their share of system resources to best serve the children in their respective schools, the central office functions as though only it knows what is best for the 185,000 children in Hawaii’s DOE.

To stay in the good graces of central administrators, principals must function more like compliance managers than leaders of their respective school communities. Principals who buck the system do so at considerable risk. Tellingly, only two in five principals said in the recent survey that they can express concern or critique DOE policies and practices without fear of reprisal, retaliation, or being unfairly evaluated.

When school-level leaders are treated this way, it is hardly surprising that the DOE’s prevailing culture is one of keeping your head down, not making waves, pretending not to see obvious problems.

The DOE’s food services branch serves more than 100,000 meals a day at an annual cost to Hawaii’s taxpayers of $110 million. A private enterprise of this magnitude would call for proven leadership, yet the DOE treats this like a rank-and-file position paying only slightly more than the average teacher’s salary.

The system’s food service manager should be responsible for providing budgetary oversight and rigorous management of costs, but that is impossible because each school’s food service manager reports only to the principal, whose budget is totally unaffected by food service costs.

Is it any wonder that the per-student cost of food service at one school can be twice the per-student cost at an otherwise comparable school?

Ray L’Heureux, a retired Marine, is vice president/vice-chairman of the Education Institute of Hawaii and a former assistant superintendent in the state Department of Education’s Office of School Facilities and Support Services.